We are getting Jon to work through his back catalogue of armies. This week he gave us the US invasion of Cuba in 1898, when they went to help the Cuban rebels throw off their Spanish Imperial Overlords. We refought an early engagement, Las Guasimas, with the invasion force trying to capture a key road junction, and just "have at" the Spaniards. The Spanish are fighting a rear guard action to allow their hospital train to escape. A lot of the battle was fought in heavy jungle.
Ian & I took the Spaniards, with Richard, Chris K, Will and Steve as the Americans. The camera is behind the Spanish lines. The markers are our concealed troops. Half of these are dummies to confuse the enemy. Dark green is heavy jungle, light green spaces on the board is light jungle.
Chris and Will on the US left dispersed into open order and pushed on as quickly as they could. Steve was ordered to come up the main road, whilst Richard immediately headed off to the flanks through the heavy jungle to turn the position apparently blocking the road.
We abandoned the farm (it was a dummy) as the US troops surged forwards. Ian popped out some men in firing line and opened fire.
Will tried to push up the stream, but Ian leapt out of cover in the centre and fired at him. This slowed him a bit.
Richard's advance moved much quicker than I'd anticipated and he turned the line of trenches. Ian reacted and turned to face. I have since looked at the Wiki page on the battle, and the Americans came straight up the roads. I don't know if this was idiocy or that the jungle was close to impenetrable.
My unit on the hills is attacked by Chris, whilst firefights carry on elsewhere. The game countdown clock is ticking. Will the Americans run out of time?
We have a good combat turn. Chris' attack is repulsed as my brave fellows turn to face and inflict firing casualties then win the melee, destroying his unit. It was tight - my unit is reduced to a Combat Value of 1. On the right, Richard's commander is killed in the fire fight. "Oh well" he remarks "That has cost us the game". It reduces the combat value of all US troops by 1.
An interesting challenge trying to simulate warfare in jungle. There were a number of other salient issues in the battle, for example the Spanish were using Mauser repeating rifles with smokeless powder. The US troops on their left were using black powder, and were much more easy to spot historically.
In the actual battle the Americans had no real clue as to where the Spanish were, and blundered into them. The jungle was so heavy away from the roads that the flanking manoeuvre wouldn't have been possible, and they were forced to attack on a narrow frontage. The US press reported it as a famous victory. In practice the Spanish wanted to extract their hospital train and retreat. They did so and inflicted heavier losses than they took into the bargain. Jon reminded us of a remark by Teddy Roosevelt who said of the campaign in the light of the battle that if they'd been fighting English, French or Germans they'd wouldn't have lasted a week.
I like it! Good battle account, Graham. Richard was correct. The American fate was sealed when Wood went down near the crossroad.
ReplyDeleteI don't think it was as black and white as that. They still needed to be lucky in the combat to get me off the objective.
DeleteThat's both a fascinating conflict and a very nice table. What rules were you using?
ReplyDeleteThe figures, table and rules are all Jon's. This was there first run out. They're a mox of some of his other rules.
DeleteAnd interesting account - with very nice pictures - of an unusual topic.
ReplyDeleteThanks. The pictures are all screen shots, so Jon is really the photographer as well as the umpire! It is an interesting conflict, with two "modern" armies facing each other in the late 19th century.
DeleteLooked like a good game for the Spaniards
ReplyDeleteI thought we did well despite only getting a draw.
DeleteFor a win, the Spanish needed to rough up the Americans a bit more.
DeleteI tried to do that but it proved quite hard to get enough firepower in the right places to do enough damage to destroy a unit.
DeleteI thought you did well. Ian may have lost a unit or two needlessly. Had Spanish officers been on the field, the outcome could have been different. I apologize for omission. Next time will be better. I swear!
DeleteIan will always take a punt to see what happens. When it comes off it is spectacular. The Spanish officers having a siesta whilst the battle raged has a cultural feel to it.
DeleteA nice AAR there and an interesting challenge for both sides, but particularly the Americans trying to advance through the jungle. Teddy's quote at the end is rather telling.
ReplyDeleteIt is a challenge. The Americans have a stronger force, out numbering the Spanish 2:1, and a third of their units are elite Buffalo Soldiers, better than anything the Spanish have got. What stopped us getting a win was our inability to destroy any US units, whilst the wide frontage we had to cover let then get local superiority of up to 3:1 in places. The jungle slows the Americans down, but also provides cover for the approach. With out the time pressure for a win it would probably be a walk over. The Roosevelt quote is interesting. Of course there may have been a political message behind it so perhaps it shouldn't be taken at faced value. We discussed the US Army in this period with Jon afterwards. Their main recent military experience was fighting native Americans on the frontier. Their CinC did have "big battle" experience, having commanded during the Civil War for the Confederacy. Of course we British shouldn't be too smug - the following year we started to make a complete mess of fighting the Boers.
DeleteIronic isnt it The Cubans fight to remove their Spanish Colonisers only to end up having the Americans take their place as colonisers for 57 years!
ReplyDeleteThe Cubans have had it rough. The US could still have had influence post revolution but delivered then Cubans into the hands of the Soviets.
Delete