There’s one of those questionnaire things going round where
someone’s prejudices (mainly around toy soldiers and table top games) are
assembled in a list for us all to measure ourselves by.
Looking at it the late Paddy G might not score above half on
the list, and he was a proper wargamer.
As for me, I haven’t scored myself, but I’ve ploughed up
half my garden to put in a purpose built wargames room.
£500/$500 on figures my a*se.
Who’s a proper wargamer then?
Me, but I don't think that these viral blog posts are about anything other than seeing if one's story is similar to another person's story? and yes I did add my little bit to the story, just as you have done. Like you, but differently, I questioned the questions. It's all part of the story we tell to make sense of our lives.
ReplyDeleteI think you are right. It is more about validating an individual's life experiences (and getting a laugh) than making any serious point.
DeleteBut £500 on figures? That's nothing.
Don't give a bugger myself- I havn't seen the thing don't feel the need to "validate " my life but do always need to have a laugh.v Havn't spent as littel as a monkey on soldiers for years- mind you I suppose my case is a bit different
ReplyDeleteWe're all different in our own ways, - some more than others. I suspect that's the point.
DeleteIn faitness to the guy that started it, - Phil B - I don't think he meant it to be taken as a yardstick the way others have.
You are almost certainly right there- most of these things start as a larf but end up entirly different- theory of unintened consequences.
DeleteJust like throwing sticks....it all starts out as fun then someone puts a small child's eye out.
Delete;-)
Re the post title ...
ReplyDeleteYes, you _are a proper wargamer.
Phil
... and so am I :o)
Of course we are!
DeleteThis is all a bit meaningless to some (me included.) Is it possible to post the questionnaire or provide a link to it?
ReplyDeleteDerek
Sure, The original list was at: http://philbancients.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/are-you-proper-wargamer.html
DeleteI think I've rather made the point that I'm not going to re-blog it.
The Ray Mears approach would be that you're not a proper wargamer (canoeist) unless you've sculpted and cast your own armies (built your own birch bark canoe).
ReplyDeleteThis one could run and run :O)
Regards, Chris
What? The modern wargamer can barely do a head swap.
Deletehttp://jurrga.blogspot.nl/2012/11/proper-wargamers-analysing-evidence.html
ReplyDeleteAn interesting piece of analysis. I think the nature of what I find interesting in wargmaing is off the mainstram, - hence my questions haven't gone viral, unlike Phil B's, which are mainly focussed around figure based table top wargaming.
Delete